People talk
Our Guestbook
“ Great place to try... The staff here are great.... Very pleasant and helpful. I enjoyed the pizza and mozzarella sticks and definitely would have them again. The garlic knots were not good they were stale and I did not enjoy them at all. I also tried the saba-roni fries.... They were good but I would say maybe the chili sauce should be on the side... My fries got super soggy from the sauce pooling at the bottom I guess some people may like that. Overall I would go again besides those 2 problems ”
“ I got some buffalo wings from them today and they were so good! Spicy, juicy & crispy! I also got a plain slice of pizza with extra cheese & it was good too! I really liked the sauce. My only thing is the crust was a bit hard. Will be back! Spend about 12 for 8 wings & then slice. ”
“ Amazing food, owner is amazing. We moved away 4 years ago and he remembered me and my family. The quality was just as good as when we left. Highly recommended ”
“ This place was recommended to me by a coworker. I work at the high school and there's a pizza place closer but one of the other coworkers ordered from there and it did not look good so I walked to Sabatinos which is only like a 6 minute walk from the other pizza place I'd rather have good pizza then just anything. I like my pizza greasy and cheesy the peperoni was excellent. I don't live here and I don't work here regular or I would order more often but whenever I'm here I'll walk over. ”
“ My friends had the beautiful pie in the window. I ordered a gluten free option . ... if I'm ever in town again I'd definitely go back. ”
“ I stopped here today, and it was a lovely experience. The pizza was delicious. I had two of their grandma slices. It’s a great little local pizza place. ”
“ Great place. Friendly/cool staff. Everything is great. Although there is a special place in my heart for the Margherita Pizza. Definitely my favorite pizza in the area. ”
“ Yesterday I had Sabatino’s Pizza in Maplewood for lunch. I order three specialty slices, Pepperoni & Sausage, General Tso Chicken, and their Chicken Alfredo slice. I am honestly not a huge fan of Alfredo-Pizzas, but that Alfredo slice was pretty darn good. Loved the Pepperoni & Sausage slice, it had awesome flavor! The biggest surprise of all was the General Tso Chicken slice. I did not for one second think GTC would be good on a pizza, but man was I wrong. I would highly recommend any of the three and any of the slices Sab’s has to offer. Anyone in Maplewood looking for some awesome pizza, def check out Sab’s! ”
Menu
Plain Pizza
US$17.95French Fries
US$4.70The "513 Valley" Chicken Sandwich
US$12.95Papa Sab's Sausage Sandwich
US$12.95The King's Caprese Sandwich
US$10.60
About
Sabatino’s Maplewood
Welcome to the culinary world of Sabatino’s Maplewood, a gem nestled in the heart of Maplewood, NJ. Located at 513 Valley St, this inviting eatery is more than just a place to eat; it’s a community hub where flavors and friendliness collide. With a phone number at hand (+1 973-327-9977), this spot is just a call away for those craving comfort food that warms the heart.
Sabatino’s Maplewood is celebrated for its diverse menu, appealing to both casual diners and dedicated food lovers. The reviews speak for themselves. A standout dish among patrons is the pizza, which has left many delighted—including Francisco Alves, who praised the blend of flavors and the pleasant staff. Notably, the mozzarella sticks and buffalo wings have garnered acclaim for their taste, with some describing them as crispy and juicy.
However, no review is without its critiques. While the garlic knots were reported as stale by some patrons, others like Demi Porter noted the robust buffalo wings, although she suggested the crust on the pizza could use some improvement. It’s this mixture of highs and lows that adds character to the experience at Sabatino’s. As Ryan Schneider aptly highlighted, the essence of this place is the genuine care of its owner, who remembers his returning customers as if no time has passed. It’s this personal touch that fosters a sense of belonging that resonates deeply with visitors.
Each visit unveils new culinary delights. Whether it's a greasy, cheesy pepperoni pizza—called an essential by Margaret Smith—or the unique saba-roni fries, every dish seems to evoke nostalgia and excitement. Donnie Davis, who ventured into the gluten-free options, noted how welcoming the experience was, capturing the spirit of Sabatino’s: inclusive and adaptable for every palate.
Sabatino’s Maplewood is not just a restaurant; it’s a testament to community, flavor, and the joys of sharing meals with loved ones. With hearty portions and a friendly atmosphere, it offers something for everyone. So next time you're seeking a fulfilling meal in Maplewood, make your way to Sabatino’s, where the food is as warm as the smiles that greet you at the door.
Book a table